Joe Carter promptly responded to Ryan Lizza’s Michelle Bachmann piece over at First Things: A Journalism Lesson for the New Yorker | First Things
Had Lizza simply stuck to such idiotic “gotcha” tactics I wouldn’t have given the article a second thought. I don’t have much interest in the presidential campaign of [...]
One Catholic Church?
James Davison Hunter says that, “…Christianity in North America…is a weak culture; weak insofar as it is fragmented in it’s core beliefs and organization, without a coherent collective identity and mission, and often divided within itself, often with unabated hostility.”
My question: “what’s the solution?”
Defending Christendom
There’s a lot in Peter Leithart’s interview with Jason Hood at the Society for the Advancement of Ecclesial Theology’s website, so I won’t try to summarize it all. Leithart is, as he says, “an advocate of Christendom” who believes that Christians are to tell rulers that they must “kiss the Son” [...]
Losing Old Church Buildings
I’m hearing that the court case against the Virginia CANA churches may not go well. Truro, Falls Church and others may be forced to leave their historic buildings. I’ve never been a fan of the “defend the property” strategy, but this is still very sad news. Turning [...]
Women in the Reformation
Justin Holcomb, writing at The Resurgence blog, writes short descriptions of the lives of several women that God used in the 16th century. Here was one that I found particularly interesting:
Olimpia Fulvia Morata was an Italian scholar born in Ferrera as the oldest child of a humanist scholar, who, after [...]
Mark Horne Needs to Chill Out about John Piper's Veteran's Day Post
I think Horne should have heeded his suspicions in his first words, “Perhaps I’m over-reacting”. Read Piper’s brief post: http://desiringgod.org/blog/posts/thankful-they-embraced-the-risk
And then compare with Horne’s reaction. You woulda thunk Piper gave an apologetic for WWI from Horne’s response. He honestly sounds like he is ranting and raving and it [...]
Thomas Cranmer desired a general council of the Protestant churches to unite them in confession and form a western, Protestant Church. Oh that it would have happened! God in his providence did not see fit for that to occur. But here is Calvin’s response to Cranmer on the subject:
I know [...]
Hyde, Daniel R.. Welcome to a Reformed Church: A Guide for Pilgrims. Orlando, Fla.: Reformation Trust Pub., 2010. Print.
Reformation Trust provided this copy for a honest review on my part, so here it is:
Rev. Hyde offers readers a primer on the history and doctrine of the Reformed Church, focusing mainly [...]
Isaiah 53 teaches us that Christ would live a sinless life, bear the guilt of mankind on His shoulders, and die as a substitute for sinners in their place. The doctrine of penal substitution states that God gave himself in the person of his Son to suffer instead of us the death, punishment and curse [...]
I liked Peter Leithart’s quotation and explication of Martin Bucer’s words. This was his short post:
Bucer wrote, “Because by faith we embrace this righteousness and benevolence of God, it shines in us, and thus he imparts himself, so that also we, too, are driven by some zeal for righteousness.”
He’s [...]
I listened to this interview on NPR’s Fresh Air while washing the dishes today. Terry Gross talked to journalist Isabel Wilkerson about her book The Warmth of Other Suns: The Epic Story of America’s Great Migration. The Great Migration, in which over 6 million African Americans moved [...]
Book review: “Eccentric Culture,” by Rémi Brague
Eccentric Culture is a brief book (less than 200 pages), but dense and challenging. It also has a fairly simple thesis: European culture is essentially Roman. Rather than a combination of Jewish and Greek culture alone, with the Romans merely passing these elements on (I posted about Brague’s critique of that attitude
American Slavery, Northern Complicity, and "Natural" Law
I continue my review of Andrew Napolitano’s, “Dred Scott’s Revenge: A Legal History of Race and Freedom in America” with this second installment on his 2nd chapter, “American Slavery”.
Napolitano shares what the typical life of the slave was like, involving being broken in, strict codes of [...]
Book review, “King Leopold’s Ghost” by Adam Hochschild
I found this review that I wrote for my own memory after I read King Leopold’s Ghost in the winter of 2007-2008, and I figured that I would post it here. I edited it a bit today (although it still suffers from my overuse of parentheses). This is definitely one [...]
We often hear that people don’t know much history anymore. Some studies suggest that there’s never really been a golden age (at least in America) when everyone knew our history, but I think that it is true that with pluralism and the damaging of consensus in the last 40-50 years there’s less cultural expectation that [...]
Hope Under Tyrrany
I finally read Animal Farm recently. I had read 1984 about 15 years ago and enjoyed it, but had never followed it up with Orwell’s other famous work. I was struck by the way that both novels end it such a bleak place, with the terrible system triumphing over [...]
“Dred Scott’s Revenge: A Legal History of Race and Freedom in America” by Andrew Napolitano (2009). Nashville, TN: Thomas Nelson.
A review by Rick Hogaboam for Booksneeze as part of their blogger program.
I rarely read books apart from the topics of theology, Biblical study, etc., but chose to delve into a [...]
Peter Leithart quotes historians Luther Peterson and R. Po-Chia Hsia’s contentions that the desire for confessional uniformity (whether Catholic, Lutheran, or Calvinist) in the 16th and 17th centuries helps to explain “he transformation of medieval feudal monarchies into modern states, in particular how the new states changed their inhabitants into disciplined, [...]
American Saints and Relics
No, I don’t just copy everything Peter Leithart writes and then post it on my blog. But it wouldn’t be a terrible idea. This post of his is short enough that I’m just going to copy and post it here. Really interesting stuff. I’m enjoying catching up on his blog after [...]
Leithart passes on Mack Holt’s observation that the French wars of religion make sense not as conflicts over beliefs but as conflicts over what kind of society they would have:
Religion at that time should be seen as “a body of believers rather than the more modern definition of a body of beliefs.” [...]
Leithart writes that Augustine saw apologetic significance of the fulfillment of Old Testament prophecies in the triumph of Christianity in the Roman Empire:
We might expect Augustine to launch into a detailed analysis of how the prophecies of the Old Testament were fulfilled in the gospel accounts, but he goes elsewhere. [...]
Peter Leithart wrote a short post on a piece by 19th-century Russian philosopher Ivan Kireevsky. Leithart notes that Kireevsky was a Slavophile, which from my understanding means a defender of the uniqueness and superiority of Slavic culture over Western European culture. Russian Slavophiles often believed that Russia was the natural leader [...]
Richard Fletcher [Continue Reading →
Peter Leithart passes on an observation from William Cavanaugh’s Theopolitical Imagination: the Reformation took hold in kingdoms where unresolved tensions remained between the monarchy and the papacy. In France and Spain, the papacy had ceded powers to the kings, and thus the monarchies lacked [...]
Justin, Trypho, and Spiritual Gifts
Here are some quotes from Ronald Kydd’s volume, “Charismatic Gifts in the Early Church”:
Kydd (1997:27) notes that Justin Martyr (100-168? A.D.), in his dialogues with Trypho, actually taught that Spiritual gifts existed, not due to some “apostolic” pre-canon ad hoc intent, but as part of the ongoing ministry of Christ to His people:
…Justin [...]
Through reading Litfin’s Getting to Know the Church Fathers, I found out that the short narrative of Justin’s martyrdom is online at the Christian Classics Ethereal Library, maintained by Calvin College. Justin and others were arrested in Rome about AD 165. The prefect (chief magistrate) of Rome [...]
Ignatius, bishop of Antich, wrote 7 letters on his way to be martyred in Rome, addressed to his friend Polycarp, bishop of Smyrna, and to the churches in Rome, Ephesus, Tralles, Smyrna, Philadelphia, and Magnesia. He appears to have died as a martyr around AD 110. In each letter, he refers to himself as “Theophorus,” [...]
I’ve been episodically reading David Engel’s Zionism in Pearson’s “Short Histories of Big Ideas” series. It seems like a good, fair, and readable introduction to the topic.
He distinguishes Zionism from “activist messianism.” The latter, a religious movement, grew in the 16th and 17th centuries and resulted in [...]
That would be Charles Simeon, the great Anglican is who is perhaps unknown to many. John Piper had some great comments about Simeon (link).
Having just read through a biography of Simeon, I find him one that I aspire to model my own life and ministry after (less the [...]
My first response to Noll’s work is to express my appreciation and respect for the amount of research and expertise that went into writing America’s God. Noll has a tremendous grasp of the different theological traditions of 18th- and 19th-century America, and displays impressive familiarity with the broader history of the [...]
Lincoln Bests the Theologians
The last major chapter of America’s God compares the subtlety and humility of Lincoln’s Second Inaugural Address in March 1865 with the way that theologians talked about the Civil War, which Noll finds predictable and self-righteous. Noll writes that while American theologians in the mid-19th century often believed that they could [...]
The free market and American Christianity
In my last post, I summarized Mark Noll’s (America’s God) belief that American evangelicals in the early 19th century generally accepted the developing free market, which brought great economic and social change to the new U.S. I thought that Noll’s fuller explanation deserved an extended quote:
European Protestants, who for the [...]
Noll now explores the changes in American theology that came after independence. Noll believes that the new, republican order that overturned the religious and social establishments of the colonial period needed new institutions, and the expanding evangelical churches provided just that. See this post for my summary of his explanation.
Chapter [...]
American hermeneutics and slavery
After chronicling the Americanization of Calvinist and Methodist theology, Mark Noll in America’s God turns to American biblical hermeneutics, the way that Americans read the Bible, in Chapters 18-20. Noll argues that the American approach to Scripture in this period also came from both their Protestant heritage and their revolutionary/early national [...]
Calvinism and Methodism get Americanized
Chapters 13-17 of America’s God consider the process by which the two major theological traditions in early America became Americanized; in other words, each began using the language and assumptions that fit with the broader culture’s republican and commonsense philosophies. This meant the softening of beliefs about man’s inherent and inherited [...]
Theological innovations in the American republic
Chapter 12 of America’s God explains the tenets of what Noll calls “American theology.” He believes that as American evangelicals built a new culture, they also absorbed its assumptions; having torn down traditional authorities, they instead defended Christianity or their denominations with the language of republicanism and commonsense moral ideas rather [...]
Scholars have begun to think about the way that Jesus and Paul called the Roman Empire into question. I think that it was this Christian Century article from 2005 that turned me on to the trend. Peter Leithart’s article in First Things also explored the idea of Paul’s assertion of Christ’s [...]
Chapter 10 of America’s God discusses the cultural consequences of the rapid expansion of evangelicalism. How, he asks, did evangelicalism come to play such an important role in the culture?
While crediting the interpretations of Gordon Wood, Robert Wiebe, and Nathan Hatch that stress the importance of the destruction of hierarchies [...]
In Chapters 7-8 of America’s God, Mark Noll shows himself to be a careful historian as he documents how traditional and “innovative” theologies did not become “American” theologies during the period of the American Revolution. In other words, even as “commonsense” moral philosophy and republican political theory became more accepted by [...]
In Chapter 6 of America’s God, Noll continues in his exploration of how American Christianity became so connected with two streams of thought that were often associated with heresy or liberal theology in Europe: republican political thought and common sense moral philosophy.
Protestants, and especially Reformed (Calvinist) Protestants, had usually [...]
Noll’s fifth chapter analyzes the American combination of Christianity and republican political ideas, which was a rare combination in the 18th and 19th centuries. You can see my notes on his previous chapter, where he explained more about this, here.
Noll argues that the most powerful influence in combining Christian beliefs [...]
Christian orthodoxy and republican ideas: the American puzzle
Noll’s fifth fourth chapter in America’s God describes the unusual agreement between traditional Christians and republican political ideas in late 18-century America. First, we have to define republican ideology. Here’s how Noll does it:
American republican language returned constantly to two main themes: fear of abuses from illegitimate power and [...]
In Chapter 3 of America’s God, Noll writes that while Jonathan Edwards ably defended the doctrines of Calvinism in a way that understood the Enlightenment, his conception of the church represented a break with the Puritan ideal.
The Puritan covenant bound society and church under a covenant with God, using [...]
The Roots of American Theology
I’ve finally gotten a chance to begin, for at least the second time, Mark Noll’s America’s God: From Jonathan Edwards to Abraham Lincoln. He’s set out an interesting task for himself: answering the question of how theological ideas in America became so thoroughly integrated with American cultural ideas. Specifically, he [...]
If you’ve never read Martin Luther King, Jr.’s, “Letter from Birmingham Jail,” do two things. First, ask yourself, “Why not?” Then, check it out. And if you have, it never hurts to look at it again.
King’s letter is a long response to Birmingham ministers who had criticized [...]
Rick’s Book Picks
Kerusso
Queen of the Sciences
Pastoral Ministry
Word, Sacraments, and Liturgy
Christ and Culture and Misc.
Gender, Family, Misc.
Poetry
Photos
Next Question Please
For the Freeloaders
Leftover Topics (but still yummy)
Christian Publishers
Friend's Sites
- "Baseball and Faith" – Steve Cornell
- Alan Burrow (Pastor of The King's Congregation in Meridian, ID) – "Faith Working"
- Ben Howard Photography
- Blazing Hope Youth Family Ranch
- Dr. Sam Storms – "Enjoying God Ministries"
- Joe Lamay – Pastor of Sovereign Grace Fellowship (South Bay, CA) and fellow El Segundo Baseball Alum
- Joel Wilhelm – "A Living Text"
- Jonathan Griffiths (Pastor at Cornerstone Church in Nampa, ID) – "Reflective Musings"
- Michael Mulconery (Elder at Sovereign Grace Fellowship of Nampa, ID) – SGF Sunday School
- My Wife's Blog – "Beloved Stranger"
- P. Andrew Sandlin (Pastor of Church of the King in Santa Cruz, CA)
- Pastor Nick Smith's Blog – "Sylvan Manor"
- Scott Kistler – "Tempora Christiana"
- William Farley (Pastor of Grace Christian Fellowship in Spokane, WA) – "The Raven"

